Skip to content
Faizan Ali home
Menu

How to redesign your website without losing your Google traffic


Updated , 8 min read

Short answer

Most traffic lost in a redesign comes from a few avoidable mistakes. Old URLs stop working, pages that ranked get removed or cut down, or the new site launches still hidden from Google. List every page that brings visitors before you start, redirect each old URL to its closest new page, and check indexing on launch day.

A redesign is meant to bring in more business, so it’s painful when the opposite happens: the new site launches, looks great, and a few weeks later Google traffic is down and the enquiries have slowed.

It’s a common story. It’s also mostly avoidable. Google doesn’t punish new designs. It ranks pages, at specific addresses, for what they say. A redesign that changes the addresses, removes the content or hides the site by accident loses the rankings those pages had earned.

This guide covers what to do before, during and after a redesign so you keep what you’ve built.

Why traffic drops after a redesign

These are the usual causes, roughly in order of how often I see them:

  • Old URLs stop working. /services/bookkeeping becomes /what-we-do/bookkeeping, nobody adds a redirect, and every link and ranking that pointed to the old address now leads to an error page.
  • Pages that ranked are gone or cut down. A detailed page that answered a real question gets trimmed to two lines because the new design looks cleaner with less text.
  • The site launches still hidden from Google. The new site was built with a “don’t index this” setting, and nobody turned it off at launch.
  • Internal links change. Pages that used to be linked from the menu or homepage are now buried, which tells Google they matter less.
  • The new site is slower. Big images, video backgrounds and extra scripts make pages slower, especially on phones.

Redesigns often change the domain, the platform and the content all at once, which makes problems hard to trace. If you can, don’t change your domain in the same project as the design.

Before you start: list every page that matters

You can’t protect what you haven’t listed. Before anyone starts on designs, build a simple spreadsheet of the pages that bring you visitors or links:

  1. Pages that get Google traffic. In Google Search Console, open the Performance report, set the date range to the last 12 months and export the list of pages.
  2. Pages people land on. Your analytics tool shows which pages visitors arrive on first. Some get traffic from places other than Google.
  3. Pages other sites link to. Search Console’s Links report shows the pages with the most links from other websites. Those links are hard to earn, so keep them working.
  4. Everything else with an address. That includes PDFs, images that rank in image search, and old campaign landing pages. Crawl the current site with a free tool like Screaming Frog (free for up to 500 URLs) to catch what you’ve forgotten.

Save a copy of the current site’s titles, headings and text for your best pages too. You’ll want to compare them later.

Decide what happens to every old URL

Go down your list and give each URL one of three outcomes:

  • Keep the same URL. This is the safest option. If the address doesn’t change, there’s nothing to redirect.
  • Redirect it to the closest new page. Use a permanent (301) redirect, set up on the server, from the old address to the new page that covers the same thing. Point it straight to the final page, not through a chain of redirects.
  • Let it go. If a page has no traffic, no links and no replacement, it can return a 404. That’s fine.

Don’t send everything to the homepage. Someone who clicked a link about bookkeeping wants the bookkeeping page, and Google’s own guide to site moves advises against redirecting lots of old URLs to an unrelated page. Merging several old pages into one new page is fine.

When I rebuilt this site, Google was still showing links to my old resume pages and to a PDF at its old address. Both now redirect: the resume pages go to the CV, and the old PDF goes to the current one. It’s a small example, but it’s the whole job. Every address that people or Google still use should land somewhere useful.

Keep the content that ranks

A new design is a good time to improve your writing, but be careful with pages that already rank. They rank because of what they say.

  • Keep the substance. If a page answers a question in detail, the new version should too. Cutting it to a few lines can lose the ranking it had.
  • Keep titles and headings close on pages that bring in steady traffic, unless you have a clear reason to change them.
  • Keep important pages easy to reach. If a page was linked from the main menu and brought in leads, don’t bury it three clicks deep.

Improve pages that don’t perform. Leave the ones that work mostly alone.

Build it where Google can’t see it

The new site needs somewhere to live while it’s being built. Put it behind a password, or a login on your hosting platform, so Google can’t find it and index a half-finished copy of your site.

Many teams use a “noindex” setting on the test site instead. That works, but it’s the setting most often left on by mistake at launch. Google’s guide says to remove any noindex tags or robots.txt blocks that were only there during development. Put it on your launch checklist in bold.

Launch day checklist

On the day the new site goes live, check these before you celebrate:

  • Every redirect in your spreadsheet works. Click a sample yourself, and test the full list with a crawler.
  • The new site can be indexed. No leftover noindex tags, and robots.txt doesn’t block important pages.
  • Each page’s canonical tag points to its own new URL, not the old site or the test site.
  • A new sitemap lists the new URLs, and you’ve submitted it in Search Console.
  • Internal links point to new URLs directly, not through redirects.
  • Analytics and Search Console are working on the new site.
  • Every form sends to the right inbox. Send yourself a test from each one.
  • Pages are fast on a phone. Check your main pages in PageSpeed Insights.

If the domain is changing too, use the Change of Address tool in Search Console as well.

After launch: what to watch

Some ups and downs are normal while Google recrawls your site. For a medium-sized site, Google says it can take a few weeks or more to show the new URLs.

For the first month, check Search Console every week:

  • Pages report: look for pages that are “Not found (404)” or “Excluded by noindex tag” that shouldn’t be.
  • Performance: compare clicks with the same period before launch, page by page. A drop spread across the whole site is normal at first. A big drop on a few pages usually points to a missing redirect or a page that lost its content.
  • Enquiries: count them. Traffic matters only because of what it brings in.

Keep your redirects in place. Google recommends at least a year, and in practice there’s no good reason to ever remove them.

If your traffic has already dropped

If you’ve already launched and traffic is down, check these, in this order:

  1. Is the site blocked from Google by a noindex tag or robots.txt?
  2. Do your old top pages redirect to the right new pages, or show an error?
  3. Did the pages that lost the most traffic lose content, or change their title?
  4. Are those pages still linked from the menu or homepage?
  5. Is the new site much slower than the old one?

Most drops come from the first two, and both can be fixed in a day. The sooner they’re fixed, the sooner Google recrawls and the rankings come back.

Whether a redesign is coming up or the traffic has already dropped, I can look at your site and tell you what to protect or fix first. Start with a free website audit, or see how I build websites. If the site isn’t bringing in enquiries in the first place, read 11 website mistakes that quietly cost you leads before you redesign anything.

Common questions

Will a website redesign hurt my SEO?

It doesn't have to. A redesign that keeps your URLs, or redirects each old one to the right new page, and keeps the content that ranks usually holds its traffic. Most redesigns that lose traffic changed URLs without redirects, deleted pages that ranked, or launched with the site still hidden from Google.

How long does it take for rankings to settle after a redesign?

Some ups and downs are normal while Google recrawls the site. For a medium-sized site, Google says it can take a few weeks or more before it shows the new URLs. If traffic is still well down after a month or two, look for a problem rather than waiting.

How long should I keep redirects after a redesign?

Google recommends keeping them for as long as possible, and generally at least a year. In practice, there's no reason to remove them. Old links on other websites and in people's bookmarks keep working for years.

Should I redirect old pages to my homepage?

No. Send each old URL to the new page that covers the same topic. Sending lots of old pages to the homepage confuses visitors, and Google advises against it. If a page really has no replacement, let it return a 404.

Got a question this guide doesn’t answer? Email me.

hi@faizanali.dev

Get new guides by email

New guides on building software and using AI, about twice a month. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Tell me what you’re trying to solve.

Twenty free minutes. You’ll leave with a clearer scope, an honest opinion on what to build first, and no pressure to work with me.